THE PUTIN SYSTEM
English version
98’
Commentary - BOLD TYPE in black
Captions on
archive footage are in purple- bold type (archives sometimes indicated in purple
in standard type)
The ITVS in Russian
are in English subtitle form in italics
Other ITVs are all in English.
(The interviews have been transcribed directly without grammatical correction.)
Maps included in the image are noted in orange
OPENING CAPTION on black:
First image-
Doors open
TCI: 10:00:17:00
« Vladimir
Vladimirovich Putin»
TCO: 10:00:20:16
TCI : 10 :00 :50 :17
Films Grain De Sable
NDR Norddeutscher Rundfunk LRT Lithuanian Radio / Television Present
TCO: 10:00:56:04
TCI: 10:00:57:00
With the participation of France 2
TCO: 10:01:01:14
TCI: 10:01:02:11
Planète
and the support of Région Ile de France TCO: 10:01:07:08
TCI: 10:01:09:00
2nd war in Chechnya, 120 000 victims
TCO: 10:01:13:01
TCI: 10:01:16:17
Hostages taken by terrorists in Beslan school… TCO: 10:01:19:16
TCI: 10:01:20:10
Russian special
forces storm the school,
344 civilian victims
TCO: 10:01:23:20
TCI: 10:01:26:04
25% of the Russian population
lives officially below the level of poverty TCO: 10:01:30:14
TCI: 10:01:37:07
Unofficially every year
350 billion
dollars are handed over to corrupt officials
TCO: 10:01:44:01
TCI: 10:01:49:11
Anna Politkovskaya,
TCO: 10:01:52:14
TCI: 10:01:53:20
22nd journalist assassinated during
Vladimir Putin’s term of office TCO: 10:01:58:14
TCI: 10:02:02:10
Nina Khrushcheva
Historian, New York
Grand-daughter Nikita
Krushchev
TCO: 10:02:07:08
TCI: 10:02:01:11
I think that in Putin’s entourage
there are people
who implement whatever
they think, not always even explicit but whatever they think his policies should be or he wants the
policies to be. How much of it does directly comes from Putin?
How much of it just fits into the whole KGB-Stalin Putinist system which is kind of a hybrid of all of those things?
TCO: 10:02:27:02
TCI: 10:02:32:10
THE PUTIN SYSTEM TCO: 10:02:40:04
TCI: 10:02:41:23
A film by
Jean -Michel Carré And Jill Emery TCO: 10:02:46:00
TCI: 10:02:58:23
Gregory Yavlinksi
Leader Yabloko, democratic party TCO: 10:03:05:01
TCI: 10:02:52:18
One
role is to to recreate the Great Russia and to be in power of this Great
Russia. This is the goal who justifies all kind of means, whether it’s war in
Chechnya, or it’s intrigues in Ukraine or it’s manipulating by gas or it’s just putting down all opponents or it’s
just control of media or it’s just special relations with Iran …whatever!
TCO: 10:03:20:01
TCI: 10:03:22:21
In March 2000 Vladimir Putin, an obscure ex KGB man, is elected as president of Russia
TCO: 10:03:30:10
TCI: 10:03:31:22
What thoughts cross the new president’s mind as he climbs these stairs to the throne of the Czars?
Is he thinking of his games on the banks of the Néva in Leningrad, now called St Petersburg once more?
Of when he was king of the gang in the communal appartment block where his family shared two rooms?
Is he picturing the heroes of his youth like Yuri Gagarine … sensing the presence of the Czars whose shadows linger within these walls?
Or is his mind fixed on the « mission » he has set himself, to save Russia, at whatever cost, from the chaos left by his predecessor Boris Yeltsin?
TCO: 10:04:09:00
Archives : soviet parades
TCI: 10:04:17:11
Patriotic and fascinated by czarist imperialism, in his youth Vladimir Putin was also deeply influenced by the soviet régime. The country, that has elected him, is eager for a new hero who will revive national strength and pride, even the memories of Stalin’s purges seem obliterated by disillusion with the present. The Russian people are nostalgic for past glory.
TCO: 10:04:42:16
TCI: 10:04:51:13
The first key to Vladimir Putin’s future destiny is his early passion for the secret service. As a boy he spends hours at the local cinema watching a Stalinist classic: « The Heroic deeds of a secret agent ». Single handed, the hero changes the destiny of a whole nation…
TCO: 10:05:08:15
Spy Film Archive:
TCI: 10:05:11:12
If you want to be a spy,
you need special talent, TCO: 10:05:15:11
TCI: 10:05:16:11
a special nose,
TCO: 10:05:17:20
TCI: 10:05:19:13
special eyes…
TCO: 10:05:20:24
TCI: 10:05:22:11
And love for one's
country no doubt
?
TCO: 10:05:25:03
TCI: 10:05:25:20
Sentimentality!
TCO: 10:05:28:02
TCI: 10:05:29:16
Viktor Borissenko Classmate
TCO: 10:05:33:01
TCI: 10:05:28:07
One day he came to see me and said,
TCO: 10:05:31:16
TCI: 10:05:31:22
"How does one join the organisation?
TCO: 10:05:34:18
TCO: 10:05:34:18
I've got a friend
who wants to enroll ".
TCO: 10:05:37:22
TCI: 10:05:38:03
My brother had a friend who worked for the KGB.
TCO: 10:05:41:07
TCI: 10:05:41:12
I told Putin I would find
out.
TCO: 10:05:45:05
TCI: 10:05:46:14
Vera Gurevich
Young Putin's German teacher
TCO: 10:05:50:14
TCI: 10:05:45:14
He started to put locks on
everything.
TCO: 10:05:28:02
TCI: 10:05:52:02
His desk was empty, nothing
but the daily papers.
TCO: 10:05:57:07
TCI: 10:05:58:23
" Well, well, I said to myself,
TCO: 10:06:00:14
TCI: 10:06:00:20
where on earth can our young man
be working
TCO: 10:05:28:02
TCI: 10:06:03:08
to have become so meticulous? "
TCI: 10:06:07:14
TCI: 10:06:08:16
At the age of 16 Vladimir Putin knocks on the door of the KGB headquarters in St Petersburg and asks to join. He is told that the KGB, alone, decide who and when they recruit. However, they advise him to study languages and law… Vladimir Putin is 23 and in his fourth year at law school when the organisation contacts him.
TCO: 10:06:32:19
TCI: 10:06:34:23
Oleg Kalugin
Former Head of KGB American Citizen TCO: 10:06:39:22
TCI: 10:06:34:16
Mr
Putin belongs to that generation of Russians who joined the KGB in 1975 when they knew perfectly well about the crimes committed
by Stalin, about the
role the soviet’s state security played in the dramatic history of my country.
TCO: 10:06:52:19
TCI: 10:06:54:07
Loubianka, KGB Headquarters
Moscow 1976
TCO: 10:06:58:13
TCI: 10:06:59:13
When Putin joins the KGB the chairman is Yuri Andropov, who was later to replace Leonid Brezhnev as head of state. The KGB represented the nation’s elite for Andropov and helped him rule the country with an iron fist, persecuting political dissidents. But Andropov also knew that if the USSR was to survive it needed to drastically reorganize its economy.
TCO: 10:07:23:10
TCI: 10:07:26:01
Vladimir Bukovsky Former dissident, London TCO: 10:07:30:00
TCI: 10:07:25:09
The
soviet leadership realized that they were in a deep structural crisis by
beginning of eighties. Andropov understood that they had to prepare some
changes because otherwise the country would collapse. It was done secretly, it
was not announced to the public, it was done quietly. They worked out the whole policy of perestroika which later
Gorbatchev inherited.
TCO: 10:07:50:16
TCI: 10:07:53:13
Today, Putin continues to pay homage to his mentor. Yuri Andropov unknowingly transmitted his vision of the State and his economic objectives to Vladimir Putin, influencing his own politics.
TCO: 10:08:06:02
TCI: 10:08:08:18
KGB (FSB) Canteen
Moscow
TCO: 10:08:11:18
TCI: 10:08:09:04
Putin’s portrait now dines in the private restaurant of Loubianka, at KGB headquarters in Moscow in the company of former chairmen like himself: Yuri Andropov, the tchékist Félix Dzerzinsky, Lavrenti Beria, notorious executer of Stalin’s purges: All of them are Putin’s proud heritage.
TCO: 10:08:27:03
TCI: 10:08:33:02
Nina Krushcheva Historian, New York
Grand-daughter Nikita Krushchev TCO: 10:08:38:01
TCI: 10:08:28:16
He is a man for all people!
He’s for the past, he’s for the future. It’s very hard to
sort of distinguish all those currents in him that makes him a great man… or a
great president for a country that is obsessed with its own greatness and its
own image. You know, I think Putin is using Kruschev’s car of 1956… It’s a
sign. I
mean, in terms of PR what it means
is “I’m using
his car, I’m a descendant of his politics.”
TCO: 10:08:59:24
George W. Bush TCI: 10:09:05:20
We're having so much fun,
we're going for another lap! TCO:
10:09:08:10
TCI: 10:09:13:16
The young KGB officer’s first post is in St Petersburg where, as a minor officer he is involved in the hunt for dissidents. Ten years later, he is posted to Dresden in East Germany.
TCO: 10:09:25:10
TCI: 10:09:26:04
With the help of the Stasi, East German secret services, his mission is to recruit informers. Inspired by Andropov he also builds a network of business contacts which will be very useful in later years.
TCO: 10:09:38:17
TCI: 10:09:40:19
Berlin 1989
TCO: 10:09:43:12
TCI: 10:09:39:21
Up graded to Lieutenant colonel, Putin is still in Germany at the fall of the Berlin wall.
TCO: 10:09:44:13
TCI: 10:09:46:20
The world around him collapses.
He asks for military support… the Kremlin remains silent. Putin feels that he and his country have been betrayed.
He has no other choice than to return to St Petersburg.
It is probably at this moment that his vision for the future of the country is born.
TCO: 10:10:07:06
TCI: 10:10:08:19
Appointed as a reserve officer at the University of St Petersburg Putin encounters his former law professor, Anatoli Sobchak, an ally of Boris Yeltsin the democrat reformer.
TCO: 10:10:19:23
TCI: 10:10:21:19
At that time General Oleg Kalugin is the head of the KGB in St Petersburg and in command of 3000 officers.When Kalugin later criticises Putin’s war in Chechnya, Putin accuses him of treason: he is forced to leave Russia TCO: 10:10:37:03
Oleg Kalugin TCI: 10:10:37:22
Sobchak the man who was one of the earlier Russian
reformers said: “Oleg,
I’m looking for some guy from the KGB in St Petersburg, who I could rely on. Could
you offer me some name? Someone? Because listen, I do not know the organization
and I know I could not be the mayor of the city without having some friends or
some kind of a relationship inside.
TCO: 10:11:00:18
TCI: 10:11:02:11
Putin joins Sobchak’s election campaign team and helps him become mayor of the city. It is a decisive moment in the KGB officer’s career: his first entry into politics. The KGB needs inside informers. Putin becomes the link between the organization and Sobchak.
TCO: 10:11:20:06
TCI: 10:11:32:00
Yuri Felshtinsky Historian
Co author "Blowing up Russia" TCO: 10:11:35:23
TCI: 10:11:21:16
The idea was to identify people
who are going to become
major political players in Russia within the next 5, 10,
15, 20 years and to put enough KGB personel around those people to secure that
when those people will be moved to the next position, those people from KGB are
going to be around and that’s how you secure that the system (in this
particular case the KGB system), will stay into power. And that’s exactly
what’s happening with Vladimir Putin.
TCO: 10:12:02:16
TCI: 10:12:07:03
Putin feels at home with the KGB strategy of control, discreetly, observing and learning, never revealing personal ambitions.Throughout his career this will be one of the keys to his own system.
TCO: 10:12:20:07
TCI: 10:12:29:00
In 1991 a wind of revolt sweeps through the soviet republics. Vladimir Putin is 39 and the USSR is in its last throes.
TCO: 10:12:38:13
TCI: 10:12:43:12
Moscow August 1991
TCO: 10:12:47:07
TCI: 10:12:39:08
President Gorbatchev plans political reforms considered dangerous by the conservative KGB generals. They attempt a putsch. With Gorbatchev’s blessing the democrat reformer and leader of the Russian Republic, Boris Yeltsin, leads the resistance against the putschists.
TCO: 10:12:56:02
TCI: 10:12:57:01
St Petersburg August 1991
TCO: 10:13:00:08
TCI: 10:12:57:24
In St Petersburg, Yeltsin’s ally, Anatoly Sobchak is also supported by the population, tired of 70 years of communist rule.
TCO: 10:13:06:12
TCI: 10:13:07:14
The putschists are defeated, the generals arrested and the KGB is in disgrace.
Putin realizes that it is in his own interests to stay with the winning camp and the reformers. Like many he resigns from the KGB but will never forget his allegiance to the organisation and its methods. During his 15 years of service he had made the KGB system his own.
TCO: 10:13:31:22
TCI: 10:13:33:05
At the end of 1991 Yeltsin declares the sovereignty of Russia, Gorbatchev resigns, the USSR is dismantled: the soviet republics become independant. Vladimir Putin will never forget these events, which later he declares were the « greatest geopopolitical catastrophe of the century ».
But did he imagine that 10 years later he would become the dauphin of Boris Yeltsin?
TCO: 10:13:56:15
TCI: 10:14:10:14
Vladimir Bukovsky Former dissident, London TCO: 10:14:15:10
TCI: 10:13:58:13
The important things which Yeltsin
did: first, he prohibited the communist party, he banned the communist party of
the Soviet Union, out of existence. That was important. That immediately took
the main core out of the whole system and it all kind of fell apart but he
didn’t finish it… That was the only thing he did.
TCO: 10:14:17:17
Yuri Felshtinski TCI: 10:14:17:18
They had
completely forgotten that the communist party was strong and powerful only
because it had during all these years the KGB behind the communist party. And
this was the irony: the communist party disappeared, the communist party was destroyed
very quickly but, everybody quietly
forgot about the KGB.
TCO: 10:14:39:11
Oleg Kalugin TCI: 10:14:43:08
In St Petersburg, as we know,
Putin was put in charge
of the Foreign Relations,
and in that capacity he served a year or so. Later,
he was picked up by Sobchak
as deputy mayor and his job as deputy mayor was privatisation which was very
lucrative... an area with lots of shadows.
TCO: 10:15:07:24
TCI: 10:15:19:03
Ludmila Narussova Sobchak Anatoly Sobchak's widow Senator
TCO: 10:15:23:17
TCI: 10:15:16:12
Vladimir Putin's
expertise was important
TCO: 10:15:18:24
TCI: 10:15:20:19
when foreign companies and banks came.
TCO: 10:15:24:09
TCI: 10:15:26:12
BNP Dresdner Bank and
Credit Lyonnais
were the first
banks
TCO: 10:15:29:06
TCI: 10:15:29:12
to open branches in
Russia.
TCO: 10:15:32:18
TCI: 10:15:30:01 CREDIT LYONNAIS
TCO: 10:15:32:06
TCI: 10:15:35:05
During the terrible winter
of 1991
TCO: 10:15:39:03
TCI: 10:15:39:08
St Petersburg was on the brink
of famine.
TCO: 10:15:41:19
TCI: 10:15:42:01
Most of the humanitarian aid came from Germany.
TCO: 10:15:46:10
TCI: 10:15:46:16
Putin organized it…
TCO: 10:15:48:09
TCI: 10:15:50:17
Putin uses his network of business friends in Germany to install a system of barter. Creating exportation licences he organizes the exchange of oil for food.
He has perhaps already realized the importance of energy as a tool for power.
TCO: 10:16:06:24
TCI: 10:16:12:02
Vladimir Ivanidze
Russian investigational journalist TCO: 10:16:17:01
TCI: 10:16:11:01
There was a lot of
cheating
around this so called
barter system.
TCO: 10:16:15:18
TCI: 10:16:17:02
The food was simply
sold
TCO: 10:16:20:04
TCI: 10:16:20:09
and the money went into the pockets
TCO: 10:16:21:21
TCI: 10:16:22:01
of officials and
those who had organized it.
TCO: 10:16:25:03
TCI: 10:16:26:13
It was a severe
crisis in Putin's
career.
TCO: 10:16:28:19
TCI: 10:16:32:08
Alexander Belayev Economist
Former town councilor St. Petersburg TCO: 10:16:37:05
TCI: 10:16:30:13
He considered economy as a
permanently controllable process. TCO: 10:16:32:19
TCI: 10:16:34:13
He wanted
more and more control all the time.
TCO: 10:16:37:24
TCI: 10:16:39:00
Different scandals mark Putin’s term of office as deputy mayor. He works with the port mafia and SPAG, a German company accused of cocaine money laundering. He manages the city casinos, whose profits disappear into thin air, gives the oil monopoly of the city to a friend …
But, times are difficult and Putin is not the only person to use organized crime networks. Now he is also in charge of law enforcement, he can do as he pleases…
He takes his « position of authority »… very seriously… TCO: 10:17:07:18
Vladimir Putin TCI: 10:17:10:11
If criminals have attacked
authority,
TCO: 10:17:14:11
TCI: 10:17:14:17
there must be
an appropriate punishment,
TCO: 10:17:17:11
TCI: 10:17:17:17
it's a policeman's duty to be severe
and cruel if necessary.
TCO: 10:17:23:14
TCI: 10:17:24:07
It
is the only way to reduce criminality, the only way...
TCO: 10:17:30:24
TCI: 10:17:31:05
We hope to eliminate 10 criminals for each officer
killed. TCO:
10:17:35:09
TCI: 10:17:35:18
…within the law, of course !
TCO: 10:17:36:24
Ludmila Narussova Sobchak TCI: 10:17:38:20
It was fascinating to observe
Vladimir Putin's metamorphosis, TCO: 10:17:43:07
TCI: 10:17:43:20
to note how quicly
he changed
TCO: 10:17:51:04
TCI: 10:17:51:20
because from a lieutenant colonel used to obeying orders,
TCO: 10:17:56:05
TCI: 10:17:57:03
he
transformed himself with great talent into a man TCO: 10:17:59:14
TCI: 10:17:59:21
who could assume responsibilities.
TCO: 10:18:02:00
Nina Krushcheva TCI: 10:18:05:09
He
strategically happened to be in all the right positions, at all in the right
times. He strategically worked for Sobchak and, as a matter of fact, doing the
KGB work for Sobchak. I actually think it’s a sign of brilliance, the fact that
he’s such a grey matter and a not a sign of his mediocrity.
TCO: 10:18:21:02
TCI: 10:18:24:11
Well established in St Petersburg, deputy mayor Vladimir Putin chooses ex KGB officers and young liberals to work at his side.
In the meantime a former member of Sobchak’s team, Anatoli Chubays a brilliant young economist, joins Yeltsin’s government in Moscow.
As his influence increases he obtains key jobs for colleagues from St Petersburg. A few years later, Putin will be the first to benefit.
Chubays invents a system of privatisation which makes a clear break with the economic rules of the soviet régime.
TCO: 10:18:58:17
TCI: 10:19:03:00
Anatoli Chubays Member of government
RAO - Russian Electricity Co TCO: 10:19:08:23
TCI: 10:19:00:07
There
was 75 years of Soviet Union when the private property was crime. That was
crime!
TCO: 10:19:08:20
TCI: 10:19:09:12
But before the fall of the Soviet Union during « perestroika » promising business men had been given state assets to « manage ». They were the first to become owners and benefit from this new system of privatisation
TCO: 10:19:19:16
TCI: 10:19:20:14
Vladimir Bukovsky
These new businessmen decided
that now they’re
free, they’re their own master. And for a while, they became what
we know as oligarchs.
TCO: 10:19:29:23
TCI: 10:19:31:06
V. Gussinsky, R. Abramovich, B. Berezovsky
TCO: 10:19:36:15
TCI: 10:19:31:10
But the oligarchs had forgotten their moral « contract » to manage the property for the state. They would learn to regret it. In the meantime, they became millionaires overnight.
TCO: 10:19:42:19
TCI: 10:19:47:17
The country is in a turmoil. Ordinary Russians quickly understand that they will not be the ones to benefit from the system of privatisation TCO: 10:19:54:20
TCI: 10:19:48:18
Moscow October 1993
TCO: 10:19:52:08
TCI: 10:19:57:06
…..as for members of the political class… their views prefer to differ. TCO: 10:20:01:23
TCI: 10:20:04:08
President Yelstin attempts to modify the constitution and impose his policy of privatization. Russian Parliament and the people resist. Yeltsin sends in the tanks…
More than 150 people are killed.
For the Russians it is the first step towards the end of their dream for democracy.
Observing the events from St Petersburg, Putin realises that from now on, in Yeltsin’s « democracy », the rules are going to be be dictated.
TCO: 10:20:34:21
TCI: 10:20:40:23
Vladimir Bukovsky
When the Soviet Union
collapsed in 1991,
“democracy” was the most popular word. Two years later it became a
swear word.
TCO: 10:20:49:21
TCI: 10:20:49:23
Nina Krushcheva
They called it “dermocracy” which is “shitocracy” if you translate
it.
TCO: 10:20:54:00
TCI: 10:20:55:18
A year later Yeltsin’s tanks move in again. This time in Chechnya.The Chechens are demanding their independance and they must be prevented from taking control over the Russian pipeline crossing their lands. After a two year war and 80 000 victims, Chechnya obtains a peace settlement in its favour.
For the Russians it is a humiliating defeat.
For Putin it is far worse, Yeltsin is guilty of committing a crime against the state: Chechnya is part of Russia, Chechnya should be forced to submit.
TCO: 10:21:28:02
TCI: 10:21:33:17
In St Petersburg, Putin organizes Sobchak’s re-election campaign as mayor.
Yeltsin has betrayed his democratic obligations and if Sobchak wins these elections Yeltsin’s old ally could become a serious contender for the presidency.
TCO: 10:21:48:03
TCI: 10:21:52:15
At Yeltsin’s request, the oligarchs refuse to help Sobtchak finance his campaign.
TCO: 10:21:57:03
TCI: 10:22:05:15
Ludmila Narussova Sobchak Anatoly Sobchak's widow Senator
TCO: 10:22:10:09
TCI: 10:22:00:16
In 1996 a man hunt
was organized
by Yeltsin.
TCO: 10:22:05:11
TCI: 10:22:07:16
He saw Sobchak as an opponent
to be removed from the political
stage.
TCO: 10:22:12:16
TCI: 10:22:12:16
Sobchak loses the elections and Putin is outraged by the increasing political power of the oligarchs.
Declaring his loyalty to his political benefactor, he refuses to work with the new mayor.
His future and that of Russia lie in Moscow. TCO: 10:22:29:03
Vladimir Bukovsky TCI: 10:22:29:24
After
being deputy mayor of St Petersburg and nearly getting himself into jail for his connections with organized crime, he was actually made an official
in the presidential
administration.
TCO: 10:22:41:23
TCI: 10:22:48:18
Noting Putin’s hard work and loyalty towards Sobchak, Anatoli Chubays finds Putin a position in the Kremlin state property department.
The 1996 presidential elections are only a few weeks off and Yeltsin’s fears are justified, he has lost the confidence of the population.
The communists are back in force, their leader, Guennady Zyuganov, is the favourite in the polls.
TCO: 10:23:10:08
TCI: 10:23:19:03
Boris Berezovsky Oligarch in exile, London TCO: 10:23:23:08
TCI: 10:23:17:07
Without politics
you’re not able to protect
your capital. Those
people, the first in
Russia, rich people, who realized they need to take political responsibility
for the future of the country because
we already felt back then that reformers held by Yeltsin are not able to stop
communism and it’s the reason why we met together to cooperate and to win the
elections.
TCO: 10:23:46:05
TCI: 10:23:47:01
From inside the Kremlin Putin watches the oligarchs transform what seemed an inevitable defeat into victory. Money and television make their stage entrance into Russian politics.
Yeltsin names Berezovsky head of the state TV and finances NTV, the private station belonging to the millionnaireVladimir Gussinsky.
Yeltsin becomes a TV Czar and television becomes the major tool for his re- election
TCO: 10:24:13:23
Boris Berezovsky TCI: 10:24:14:24
TV in Russia is not movie.
TV in Russia is politics,
no doubt. Using this
leverage, we won presidential elections.
TCO: 10:24:26:21
TCI: 10:24:29:10
Yeltsin owes his re-election to the oligarchs but in doing so he has become their hostage.
He cannot stand for a third mandate; it is already time to think about organizing his succession.
TCO: 10:24:40:17
TCI: 10:25:00:06
Yuri Felshtinski Historian
Co author "Blowing up Russia" TCO: 10:25:04:04
TCI: 10:24:42:11
It was clear from the experience which they had in
1996 that the next presidential campaign will
demand two major tools: one is a Russian TV channel which is going
to support the next president and a company
which is going financially to
stay behind the electoral campaign and support the candidate financially.
TCO: 10:25:06:13
TCI: 10:25:10:23
The oil company, SIBNEFT, is created with Roman Abramovich, Berezovsky’s intriguing young business partner as chairman. The state TV directed by Boris Berezovsky becomes a tool for state propaganda.
A system is born to promote Yeltsin’s successor. TCO: 10:25:31:05
TCI: 10:25:34:12
The elections are hardly over when Yeltsin falls ill again. He delegates his powers to the oligarchs Berezovsky and Abramovich who have won their gamble in using their money to obtain political power. They literally command the country with other members of a group known as « the family ». It includes Yeltsin’s own daughter, Tatiana and her future husband.
TCO: 10:25:56:04
TCI: 10:26:00:01
Close to this « family» Anatoli Tchubais continues to orchestrate Putin’s advancement, promoting him 3 times in 2 years. Each post enables Putin to analyse the problems specific to Yeltsin’s regime.
Using his KGB methods and training he discreetly files precious information for future purposes.
TCO: 10:26:19:02
TCI: 10:26:24:03
The oligarchs are looking for someone young, serious, but unpretentious, who will suit Yeltsin as his successor.
Obedient and efficient, Vladimir Putin seems the perfect choice. TCO: 10:26:36:14
TCI: 10:26:39:03
Gregory Yavlinski
Leader Yabloko, democratic party TCO: 10:26:43:02
TCI: 10:26:37:08
That was a typical
oligarchic decision: to find a man, who’s not independent, who’s dependent on them and
they had in mind that through him, they would operate the country.
TCO: 10:26:51:09
TCI: 10:26:56:03
Lilia Shevtsova Political analyst
Carnegy Foundation Moscow TCO: 10:27:01:02
TCI: 10:26:52:10
For some people, for some members
of Yeltsin’s family,
and also Yeltsin’s
family friends like Berezovsky, the oligarch, apparently these people
looked at Putin as some kind of an insignificant personality who could be taken
care of…who’d be their puppet on a string.
TCO: 10:27:09:20
TCI: 10:27:18:16
In 1998 the “family”propose Putin as head of the FSB, the former KGB. It is a decisive and symbolical step in his career, a chance to prove his loyalty and render important services to the régime.
TCO: 10:27:32:13
Vladimir Putin TCI: 10:27:36:06
These walls are very familiar to me,
TCO: 10:27:38:03
TCI: 10:27:40:07
I am honoured by this nomination.
TCO: 10:27:42:16
TCI: 10:27:42:22
I'd like to thank the president.
TCO: 10:27:46:00
TCI: 10:27:44:20
Although a former KGB lieutenant colonel Vladimir Putin is the first
« civilian » in history to be nominated to this post.
He now finally occupies the seat that his mentor Yuri Andropov had left 16 years earlier.
TCO: 10:27:59:10
Yuri Felshtinski TCI: 10:28:00:06
The oligarchs
were hoping that Putin, who was promoted only to the rank of lieutenant colonel,
which is not really very high, is not going to be loyal to FSB
the way any general of FSB is going to be loyal.
TCO: 10:28:20:12
TCI: 10:28:21:24
But, what the oligarchs fail to realise is that Vladimir Putin has never abandonned the KGB spirit and its ideology. He feels invested with a mission and in the shadows he patiently awaits his hour…
TCO: 10:28:36:24
TCI: 10:28:39:16
Protected by their political status, the oligarchs triple their fortunes, dilapidate millions and invest massively offshore, in the meantime many Russians are finding it hard to subsist. In summer 1998 the economic crash is inevitable.
TCO: 10:28:55:04
TCO: 10:28:56:10
Summer 1998
TCO: 10:29:00:05
TCI: 10:29:01:19
Yeltsin needs a firm hand at the helm to reassure the population. A KGB primeminister appears his best option. The first one, soviet-style Evgueny Primakhov, takes his mission too seriously and declares that he will put a halt to corruption and throw the oligarchs in jail. The population jubilates. Yeltsin and the family feel distinctly worried.
Confident in the peoples’ support, Primakov turns a blind eye. He nominates a new general prosecutor, Yuri Skuratov, to assist him. TCO: 10:29:35:24
TCI: 10:29:41:09
Skuratov’s first enquiry starts within the walls of the Kremlin itself and concerns its sumptuous renovation. 66 million dollars have been embezelled and are to be found on the bank accounts of high ranking civil servants and members of the family…The general prosecutor is treading dangerous ground.
TCO: 10:30:00:19
TCI: 10:30:03:14
Yuri Skuratov
Former General Prosecuter Russia TCO: 10:30:07:20
TCI: 10:30:02:09
The enquiry
wasn't technically complicated
TCO: 10:30:04:16
TCI: 10:30:05:10
but, proceedings were difficult
TCO: 10:30:07:10
TCI: 10:30:07:23
because Mr Yeltsin was directly
involved. TCO:
10:30:09:20
TCI: 10:30:12:23
Oleg Kalugin
Former Head of KGB American Citizen TCO: 10:30:17:12
TCI: 10:30:10:05
And Yeltsin could
not throw the prosecutor out because he had no legitimate legal power so he asked Mr Putin: “Could
you do anything?” and he said: “Ja wohl! No problem, we’ll do it”. So, you know the prosecutor
was framed at the KGB safe house with some of the prostitutes and it was all on
camera and shown on Russian television.
TCO: 10:30:35:10
News TV (subtitles)
TCI: 10:30:37:04
The director of the FSB, Vladimir
Putin,
TCO: 10:30:39:08
TCI: 10:30:39:15
has announced that the pictures
of the man ressembling
TCO: 10:30:41:23
TCI: 10:30:42:05
Yuri Skuratov, the general
prosecutor,
TCO: 10:30:45:07
TCI: 10:30:45:18
are authentic.
TCO: 10:30:47:05
TCI: 10:30:49:21
Skuratov is forced to resign. TCO: 10:30:52:05
Oleg Kalugin TCI: 10:30:53:03
Putin,
in the eyes of Yeltsin, became someone who would never let him down, and in
that sense he was probably right, Putin keeps his word, I mean and in that sense, he knows his superiors
and he has never betrayed
them so far, that’s a fact,
it’s part of his character.
TCO: 10:31:11:09
TCI: 10:31:13:01
For Yeltsin, Mr Putin, the Director of the FSB, has passed his test. He deserves a reward.
TCO: 10:31:19:05
TCI: 10:31:23:16
9th August, 1999
TCO: 10:31:26:11
Yeltsin
TCI: 10:31:22:09
And now I have decided
to give you the name of the man
TCO: 10:31:27:04
TCI: 10:31:27:10
who, in my eyes, is capable consolidating our society, TCO: 10:31:35:15
TCI: 10:31:36:06
Vladimir, Vladimirovich Putin.
TCO: 10:31:39:06
TCI: 10:31:40:10
Putin’s nomination as primeminister in August 1999 confirms that he has been approved of by the whole « family, » but he is still unknown to the population.
TCO: 10:31:49:13
TCI: 10:31:52:03
Serguey Kovalev
Former dissident and MP TCO: 10:31:56:16
TCI: 10:31:50:10
Everybody was asking
" Who is this Putin ?”
TCO:
10:31:52:07
TCI: 10:31:52:12
Remember that question?
TCO: 10:31:54:05
TCO: 10:31:54:11
" Who is Mr Putin ? "
TCO: 10:31:56:03
TCI: 10:31:57:03
So he had to show who he was.
TCO: 10:32:00:06
TCI: 10:32:00:24
And then came the explosions in the
Moscow appartment blocks!
TCO: 10:32:04:10
TCI: 10:32:07:11
In 3 weeks, explosions in several Russian towns kill 300 people. The government immediately accuses the Chechen rebels. But when another explosion is nipped in the bud and two terrorists are arrested, the Kremlin surprisingly orders the police to stop enquiries… Journalists discover what could well become a state affair, the « terrorists » in question are in fact members of the FSB.
TCO: 10:32:30:21
TCI: 10:32:36:02
Yuri Felshtinski Historian
Co author "Blowing up Russia" TCO: 10:32:40:15
TCI: 10:32:33:04
And
that’s how for the first time Russian public opinion realized that the
terrorist acts which
took place in Moscow and Volgodonsk and Buynaksk might be the work of the FSB.
TCO: 10:32:47:14
NTV extract
TCI: 10:32:51:07
NTV, the TV station belonging to Vladimir Gussinsky broadcasts a debate on the implication of the FSB in the explosions where FSB officials accuse one another of collusion.
TCO: 10:33:02:06
TCI: 10:33:09:08
The public still finds this hard to believe, but journalists are pursuing their investigations and as primeminister, Putin realizes that there is no time to be lost. He must create a diversion. He decides to exploit the population’s hatred for the Chechens.
TCO: 10:33:25:08
TCI: 10:33:31:06
Gleb Pavlovsky Political technologist Putin's advisor TCO: 10:33:36:03
TCI: 10:33:26: 04
Chechnya has always been the politician's grave.
TCO: 10:33:28:19
TCI: 10:33:29:20
A lot of people
were afraid
TCO: 10:33:32:00
TCI: 10:33:32:13
and thought that Putin should keep his distances, TCO: 10:33:36:00
TCI: 10:33:36:18
but he was obstinate.
TCO: 10:33:39:24
TCI: 10:33:40:06
To general surprise,
TCO: 10:33:43:09
TCI: 10:33:43:15
it played in his favour.
TCO: 10:33:45:03
Putin
TCI: 10:33:46:03
These people aren’t human beings.
TCO: 10:33:48:23
TCI: 10:33:49:13
They are animals,
TCO: 10:33:50:24
TCI: 10:33:52:13
wild animals
TCO: 10:33:54:04
Gleb Pavlovsky TCI: 10:33:54:18
The middle class became
angry
TCO: 10:33:57:10
TCI: 10:33:59:21
Putin reacted in the same way.
TCO: 10:34:03:08
TCI: 10:34:04:13
This is when he started to build
his image saying,
TCO: 10:34:08:10
TCI: 10:34:09:06
"I'm a man like you,
TCO: 10:34:11:15
TCI: 10:34:12:20
I'm primeminister, but I'm the same as you"
TCO: 10:34:15:22
Vladimir Putin TCI: 10:34:16:12
We will pursue the terrorists everywhere,
TCO: 10:34:19:19
TCI: 10:34:20:02
we'll eliminate them in the
shit house, if we have to. TCO:
10:34:22:15
TCI: 10:34:22:22
That's my last word.
TCO: 10:34:26:09
Gleb Pavlovsky TCI: 10:34:27:03
This is when Putin becomes Putin,
TCO: 10:34:29:12
TCI: 10:34:30:00
he acquires his own language,
TCO: 10:34:33:06
TCI: 10:34:33:11
total freedom of expression
TCO: 10:34:35:01
TCI: 10:34:35:06
and complicity with the Russian people.
TCO: 10:34:39:14
TCI: 10:34:39:19
He is no longer
afraid of his public
TCO: 10:34:42:07
TCI: 10:34:51:20
Vera Gurevich
Young Putin's school teacher TCO: 10:34:56:12
TCI: 10:34:43:03
As for his words
"We'll get them in the shit house",
TCO: 10:34:45:23
TCI: 10:34:46:09
I scolded him for that.
TCO: 10:34:48:09
TCI: 10:34:49:00
"Where did you get that expression?” TCO: 10:34:51:10
TCI: 10:34:51:16
"Shit house,
I've never heard anything like it!"
TCO: 10:34:55:05
TCI: 10:34:55:21
"I just couldn't hold myself back any longer!” he said.
TCO: 10:34:59:19
TCI: 10:35:01:18
For the last three centuries, many Russians and their leaders have resented the Chechen «bandits», as they call them. The Chechens have always
refused to submit to Russian dominance. Stalin deported them by thousands…
Yeltsin’s peace treaty is still felt as a humiliation and for the population the recent explosions are a provocation… Their primeminister Vladmir Putin is entirely justified in declaring a new war.
TCO: 10:35:26:16
TCI: 10:35:28:15
Berezovsky asks Serguey Dorienko, the star journalist of his TV station, to put his political news magazine at the service of Vladimir Putin.
TCO: 10:35:36:13
TCI: 10:35:41:24
Serguey Dorienko Journalist
TCO: 10:35:46:02
TCI: 10:35:38:16
He often asked me in private
TCO: 10:35:41:14
TCI: 10:35:41:19
to provoke the situation
TCO: 10:35:44:06
TCI: 10:35:44:24
For example, when I demanded that our army attack Chechnya,
TCO: 10:35:48:21
TCI: 10:35:49:04
he said, "say it on
the air… "
TCO: 10:35:51:21
TCI: 10:35:52:04
"I had already planned
to," I said
TCO: 10:35:54:10
TCI: 10:35:54:19
Putin answered,
TCO: 10:35:56:09
TCI: 10:35:56:22
“I want you to say it for me,
TCO: 10:35:58:03
TCI: 10:35:58:07
we'll see how people
react."
TCO: 10:36:00:19
TCI: 10:36:01:19
He wanted
to get a feeling of the
population through me.
TCO: 10:36:09:02
TCI: 10:36:16:12
Grozny October 1999
TCO: 10:36:19:24
TCI: 10:36:16:09
On the 1st of October Russian bombers attack Grozny, the capital of Chechnya. With Berezovsky’s state TV and the population behind him Putin throws Russia into a ferocious war. The Chechen people are the victims of unprecedented barbarity.
TCO: 10:36:34:13
TCI: 10:38:35:21
Yuri Felshtinsky Historian
Co author "Blowing up Russia" TCO: 10:38:40:06
TCI: 10:38:35:04
Putin showed that he was capable of making a firm political stand TCO: 10:38:41:15
TCI: 10:38:43:04
and of taking difficult political decisions,
TCO: 10:38:49:02
TCI: 10:38:49:25
that he was the ideal
military leader
for the country.
TCO: 10:38:57:20
TCI: 10:37:01:11
Satisfied with his conduct, the “family” decides to create a political party for Putin to lead in the next parliamentary elections. There are two months to go.
Made to measure by Boris Berezovsky, « Unity », later to become « United Russia », has a single item on its agenda: the promotion of Vladimir Putin. If his party wins he will be confirmed as a legitimate successor to Boris Yeltsin.
The state TV and Abramovich and his oil company, Sibneft, provide media and financial support.
TCO: 10:37:30:02
TCI: 10:37:32:13
This time, Gussinsky and his station NTV, who are against the war in Chechnya, support Putin’s main rival, the former primeminister Evgueny Primakov…
Berezovsky sinks to the lowest tricks to discredit the enemy. TCO: 10:37:44:20
Boris Berezovsky TCI: 10:37:45:09
To be sure, we used election
technology which is very specific
in Russia. We used
the power of the mass media and not in a soft
way like you use it in the West: In very strong and very hard
way.
TCO: 10:38:02:04
TCI: 10:38:04:16
19th December 1999
TCO: 10:38:08:06
TCI: 10:38:04:03
Mission accomplished for Berezovsky. Unity’s score confirms Putin’s political dominance.
Everyone gets ready for the New Year’s Eve festivities, unaware that behind the Kremlin walls, Yeltsin and his primeminister Vladimir Putin are preparing the final act to the strategy of these last months…
On the 31st of December Yeltsin summons Putin to his office, gives him the nuclear attaché case and names him president by interim until the presidential elections.
For his part of the deal, Putin offers Yeltsin and his family total immunity and a large pension for life: A way for Yeltsin to avoid destitution and legal pursuit for his crimes against the state.
TCO: 10:38:54:24
TCI: 10:38:59:00
But what Yeltsin probably didn’t realise is that Putin, is loyal to his
« mission » and not towards the men he has served. For him, Yeltsin is guilty of dismantling the Soviet Union, of losing the first war in Chechnya, and of leading Russia towards autodestruction.
It was essential to remove him from power once and for all. TCO: 10:39:18:13
Yeltsin
TCI: 10:39:23:01
Today is the last time
TCO: 10:39:25:15
TCI: 10:39:25:23
I address you
TCO: 10:39:27:14
TCI: 10:39:27:23
as President of Russia.
TCO: 10:39:30:02
TCI: 10:39:30:20
I'm leaving.
TCO: 10:39:33:22
TCI: 10:39:34:19
On New Year’s Eve, crowds press to the Bolshoi theatre in Moscow to catch a glimpse of Yeltsin’s chosen successor… In vain, the presidential box remains empty. Putin has lost no time in publicly showing his priorities. He and his wife have left the city the same evening to join the troops on the Chechen front. In front of the television cameras, he offers the soldiers 200 daggars, especially engraved for the occasion.
A symbolic present for the men who are fighting the Chechen guerilla. TCO: 10:40:05:10
TCI: 10:40:10:16
Symbolically also, Putin has laid the first brick to his presidential election campaign.
His image makers now have to make him a charismatic figure that will charm the Russian electorate.
TCO: 10:40:22:02
TCI: 10:40:26:10
Gleb Pavlovsky Political technologist Putin's advisor TCO: 10:40:30:19
TCI: 10:40:26:08
We advised him to show he was
TCO: 10:40:32:04
TCI: 10:40:33:12
in good health compared
with Yeltsin,
TCO: 10:40:37:19
TCI: 10:40:38:00
that he knew how to pilot
a fighter plane
TCO: 10:40:41:15
TCI: 10:40:42:07
dive in a submarine…
TCO: 10:40:45:21
TCI: 10:40:51:05
Putin is a quick learner. He learns how to appear in public, is a good sport, and appears to be a perfect gentleman… He even shows that he can smile! Radio programmes receive thousands of love letters from women infatuated with the new Russian hero…
But, a few details still need a little bit of polish… TCO: 10:41:17:06
TCI: 10:41:19:21
Vera Gurevich
Young Putin's school teacher TCO: 10:41:24:05
TCI: 10:41:20:06
I
told him "the way you walk doesn't suit a president TCO: 10:41:23:09
TCI: 10:41:23:14
you've got to work at it.
TCO: 10:41:25:11
TCI: 10:41:26:07
And please stop swaying
from left to right like a wrestler! " TCO: 10:41:29:03
TCI: 10:41:29:08
He said, "It's true,
at home they tell me I walk like a penguin ".
TCO: 10:41:33:00
TCI: 10:41:33:06
"No, it's much worse than that!
TCO: 10:41:34:24
TCI: 10:41:35:06
Spend a minute a day practicing!"
TCO: 10:41:37:23
TCI: 10:41:38:08
Now he walks completely differently
TCO: 10:41:40:21
TCI: 10:41:41:11
…but we're still working
at it!
TCO: 10:41:44:06
TCI: 10:41:54:22
While Putin takes part in village fêtes, the violence of the Chechen war, an important element in his campaign, intensifies…
TCO: 10:42:02:15
TCI: 10:42:06:10
The massacre in Chechnya doesn’t stop the Orthodox Church, from supporting Putin. Inspite of soviet repression, the population is still strongly religious.
Putin, the man of «modest origins»…, makes it known to the people that he still wears the tin cross given to him by his mother at his christening.
TCO: 10:42:24:00
TCI: 10:42:28:19
Oleg Gordievsky Former secret agent KGB - MI6
TCO: 10:42:32:24
TCI: 10:42:25:10
Now he’s very
religious and speaks, confessing to the Patriarch himself, to the head of the Orthodox
Church. The Patriarch has been for 40 years agent of the
KGB.
And who is the head of the
patriarch? General Patrouchev! Head of the KGB.
So the patriarch tells Mr
Patrouchev about everything, and Mr Patrouchev is visiting the next day the President and telling him everything! It is like a joke! TCO:
10:42:58:09
TCI: 10:43:00:20
Lilia Shevtsova Political analyst
Carnegie Foundation Moscow TCO: 10:43:05:12
TCI: 10:42:58:10
He started to
please everyone around him. He attracted reformers, liberals, democrats, nationalists, Russians and Muslims…
many people thought
he was one of theirs’… the guy
from the end of the street!
TCO: 10:43:15:07
TCI: 10:43:19:17
Only the head of the communist party Guennady Zyuganov remains a serious contender for Putin. Other candidates hardly dare criticise him. He seems to represent everything the population could desire.
TCO: 10:43:31:17
TCI: 10:43:35:06
To further convince electors Putin presents his manifesto entitled « Russia on the brink of the third millenium» in which he promises to make the country autonomous and respected in the world.
Not only the Russian electorate but also the West discovers Russia’s new face, or so they think…
TCO: 10:43:52:17
TCI: 10:43:55:07
Stephen Sestanovich
Foreign affairs Advisor USA TCO: 10:44:00:06
TCI: 10:43:53:08
Putin’s manifesto with which he presented himself
as a presidential candidate,
rather than a hero of the Chechen crack down, was a stunning document.
The text was broadly
liberal. It had a vision of the evolution of Russian
institutions which made people think that Putin was a westernizer TCO: 10:44:24:06
TCI: 10:44:27:03
Western politicians are mistaken. Putin’s political vision is different from anything in the West. He indeed promises to reform justice and the institutions, but he also talks of a managed democracy and the vertical of power. He combines, without any hesitation, contradictory values such as, liberalism and Statism, democracy and dictatorship.
Both in Russia and abroad, people only see the mark of someone capable of putting an end to political and economic chaos.
TCO: 10:44:58:05
TCI: 10:45:02:17
These elections are all but a remake of the 1996 poll. But if Zyuganov had his chances against the ailing Yeltsin, this time he has lost before he starts. Putin graciously uses him as a sparring partner to guarantee his own victory.
TCO: 10:45:17:13
TCI: 10:45:23:15
Vladimir Bukovsky Former dissident London
TCO: 10:45:27:19
TCI: 10:45:18:15
There was a very
good joke at that time…a fox asks a crow « Are you going to vote for Putin? The crow doesn’t
answer. It’s afraid of losing its cheese
when it opens its beak. «
Answer me! Are you going to vote for Putin yes or no? »
« Yes says the crow and the cheese
falls out of his mouth.
The fox runs off with the
cheese. The crow sitting sadly
on its branch meditates « What if I had said no…Would that have changed
anything?
This was a typical
Russian attitude at that time…What choice was there? The communists with Zyuganov or a
lieutenant colonel from the KGB
Is that a choice, is that a real election?
TCO: 10:46:06:00
TCI: 10:46:17:00
On the 26th March 2000, Vladimir Putin is elected outright in the first ballot with a 52% majority as President of the Federation of Russia TCO: 10:46:26:05
TCI: 10:46:27:09
I swear...
TCO: 10:46:28:10
TCI: 10:46:28:19
to
respect and defend
the rights and the freedom TCO: 10:46:32:12
TCI: 10:46:32:20
of all men and women.
TCO: 10:46:35:12
TCI: 10:46:56:06
Beyond the words of ceremony, Vladimir Putin, the man from the KGB, has not forgotten the teenage dream and his mission, to restore the nation to its former power.
His goals are to develop the strategic ressources for the state: oil, gas, the media, other industries, to restore military power and revive the sense of national pride and identity.
Putin himself owes much of his success to television, it is the first tool he needs to possess.
The oligarchs, who owned the media had monopolised political power and vandalized the state.
They had taken him for a puppet…
Now the tables had turned, Yeltsin had been evinced, it was their turn to pay for their crimes…
TCO: 10:47:42:09
TCI: 10:47:50:07
The new president uses tactics for his first move. He decides to operate through the state owned energy giant, Gazprom which has important assets in the media.
TCO: 10:47:59:21
TCI: 10:48:08:06
Vladimir Milov
Vice minister Energy
1st administration Vladimir Putin TCO: 10:48:13:07
TCI: 10:48:01:17
It is not surprising that Mr Putin,
who came into power in 2000, obviously
took this opportunity to place himself at the head of gazprom officially
naming his representative Mr Miller CEO. Mr Putin literally makes decision on
important business transactions or important investments projects by himself. This means
that he’s in fact the CEO of Gazprom.
TCO: 10:48:31:07
TCI: 10:48:33:14
In the Kremlin, Putin calls on former colleagues and ex KGB officers in St Petersburg to join his team. Alexei Miller is one of them.
TCO: 10:48:42:05
TCI: 10:48:43:00
GAZPROM is the perfect tool to attack Vladimir Gussinsky, owner of the private TV station NTV, financed by loans from the energy giant.
TCO: 10:48:52:17
TCI: 10:49:03:09
Yuri Felshtinsky Historian,
Author « Blowing up Russia » TCO: 10:49:08:06
TCI: 10:48:56:05
All Putin did was ask that the Gazprom
loan be reimbursed. From that moment
onwards Gussinsky was financially and economically ruined. It was clear that
Putin’s action was political.
TCO: 10:49:12:21
TCI: 10:49:14:10
The rebel oligarch is incarcerated in June 2000 for embezzlement. The court allows him to leave the country provided he turns over the majority of his NTV stocks to Gazprom. Under the cover of the law and the fight against corruption, Putin has started to hunt down « the enemy within » and a campaign against the independent media.
TCO: 10:49:34:22
TCI: 10:49:42:16
28th July 2000
TCO: 10:49:45:22
TCI: 10:49:36:23
Boris Berezovsky, also begins to realize that the wind has turned. Gussinsky has fled and he is the only oligarch who is not invited to the first meeting organized by Putin. To the remaining oligarchs Putin announces it is
«business as usual», but politics are out! TCO: 10:50:00:20
TCI: 10:50:02:23
Putin is beginning to show what stuff he is made of.
Berezovsky had considered him to be a mere pawn to serve his own interests…and for Putin, humiliation is a powerful incentive for cold and calulated revenge.
TCO: 10:50:15:13
TCI: 10:50:19:17
Berezovsky’s fate is strangely linked to an event that jeapodizes Vladimir Putin’s own political career.
In August 2000, 3 months after his investiture, the annual Navy exercises are to show the whole world that Russian military power is not to be underrated.
TCO: 10:50:35:13
TCI: 10:50:39:23
But, two mysterious explosions send the pride of the fleet, the nuclear submarine Kursk, to the floor of the Barents sea.
Putin refuses assistance from abroad and remains silent for several days. The 118 submariners on board perish in the depths.
The Russian people are angry and the press accuses Putin of contempt for the families.
Berezovsky, who still imagines he is the master of the situation, jumps at the opportunity to publicly denounce the president’s incompetence.
TCO: 10:51:21:16
Yuri Felshtinsky TCI: 10:51:24:19
After the Kursk affair,
Putin decided to take over Berezovsky’s television channel and this was when the
open conflict between them began.
TCO: 10:51:37:08
TCI: 10:51:37:12
Like Gussinsky, Berezovsky is accused of embezzlement and flees the country to avoid jail.
TCO: 10:51:43:15
TCI: 10:51:51:24
Lilia Shevtsova Political analyst
Carnegy Foundation Moscow TCO: 10:51:56:22
TCI: 10:51:46:22
Berezovsky wanted
to be the boss. Because
of his immense ambition, he was out. He
had to be out. The other
oligarch who was out was Gussinsky, he too wanted to be
the boss and rule Russia through television. They hadn’t understood that there
is only ever one boss in the Kremlin.
TCO: 10:52:07:16
TCI: 10:52:09:05
Gussinsky and Berezovsky have been eliminated, but their journalists refuse to believe that the freedom of the press is under attack.
To all apparence democratic, Putin allows programmes to continue. In the satirical show « Kuklies », the Russian Muppets, the journalist Evgueny Kisseliov is in the grips of an evil Vladimir Putin (Fantomas). TCO: 10:52:29:15
TCI: 10:52:32:13
Kisseliev-What's going on?
TCO: 10:52:34:21
TCI: 10:52:35:18
Putin alias Fantomas -I read the article
you wrote about
me.
TCO: 10:52:38:04
TCI: 10:52:38:22
I didn't like it.
TCO: 10:52:40:14
TCI: 10:52:41:07
Write another
one!
TCO: 10:52:43:08
TCI: 10:52:44:10
- So, you're against
the freedom
of the press?
TCO: 10:52:46:11
TCI: 10:52:46:18
-No, but either you obey,
TCO: 10:52:48:12
TCI: 10:52:49:04
or I close down your paper.
TCO: 10:52:51:19
TCI: 10:52:53:21
Moscow April 2001
TCO: 10:52:57:16
TCI: 10:52:53:15
Putin’s idea of democracy does not allow for criticism of authority. One year after his arrival in power Gazprom finalizes the take over of NTV. Early one morning armed men invade the televsion studios. When they arrive, the journalists discover that a team from the Kremlin has replaced them.
Putin gives one warning, if unheeded, he is pitiless.
Kisseliev and others find themselves jobs on a small channel still belonging to Berezovsky. A few months later it is also taken over and replaced by a sports’ channel.
TCO: 10:53:33:11
TCI: 10:53:38:22
Igor Malashenko Former oligarch Associate V. Gussinsky TCO: 10:53:43:18
TCI: 10:53:36:22
There is only one word to describe KGB mentality. That word is control.What
you control is safe. What you don’t
control is a threat. Therefore you must control as many things as possible.
TCO: 10:53:52:00
TCI: 10:54:08:06
Oleg Gordievsky Former secret agent KGB - MI6
TCO: 10:54:13:22
TCI: 10:54:00:13
A few days after the presidential elections, Putin went to the Dzerjinski club. Putin stood up on the stage in front
of 800 officers…
TCO: 10:54:13:11
Vladimir Putin TCI: 10:54:16:02
The FSB wanted to return to
power,
TCO: 10:54:21:12
TCI: 10:54:21:19
I am pleased to announce that we have succeeded.
TCO: 10:54:25:09
Oleg Gordievsky TCI: 10:54:26:16
Putin had understood that this was his card to play, as man of the KGB:
« Remember, I told you I’m your man! »
TCO: 10:54:35:15
TCI: 10:54:37:15
FSB Footage TCO: 10:54:40:05
TCI: 10:54:37:21
During the cold war, the hunt for Western spies was one of the principal activities of the KGB. Putin immediately shows the West and in particular the United States, that the secret service, now called the FSB, is in control again.
Edmond Pope, a former intelligence officer of the US Navy, is arrested and tried for spying.
TCO: 10:54:58:15
TCI: 10:55:04:24
Edmond Pope Business man
Former intelligence service US Navy TCO: 10:55:09:15
TCI: 10:55:01:10
They had to make an example
and “boom”, here comes the time, so they grab me and use me as an example. Several
of the FSB officers at the prison quite frankly told me, the reason I was there
was strictly a political event. They wanted to make a very, very clear break
from the Yeltsin administration.
TCO: 10:55:21:18
TCI: 10:55:25:10
Serguey Kovalev
Former dissident and MP TCO: 10:55:30:10
TCI: 10:55:21:23
Our country,
like any police state,
needs two enemies,
TCO: 10:55:28:21
TCI: 10:55:29:03
an enemy "within" and an enemy "without".
TCO: 10:55:31:11
TCI: 10:55:31:18
Without enemies,
this system cannot survive.
TCO: 10:55:35:02
TCI: 10:55:35:19
It's just like the Soviet Union!
TCO: 10:55:38:00
TCI: 10:55:47:22
Stalin’s national anthem returns, with the words rewritten by the same author and many older Russians are comforted to see the red flag of their youth flutter in military parades again.
TCO: 10:55:58:23
TCI: 10:56:11:21
Arseny Roginsky President Memorial NGO Human rights TCO: 10:56:16:20
TCI: 10:56:11:11
There's a marked
return of symbols like the former national anthem.
TCO: 10:56:16:23
TCI: 10:56:17:05
Putin wants to revive
the notion that we are a
great country, TCO:
10:56:21:02
TCI: 10:56:21:04
a great nation, respected
TCO: 10:56:24:01
TCI: 10:56:24:08
throughout the world, feared
even,
TCO: 10:56:27:01
TCI: 10:56:27:03
that we are of vital importance.
TCO: 10:56:29:09
TCI: 10:56:35:03
This ideology is combined
with former totalitarian reflexes, TCO: 10:56:38:10
TCI: 10:56:38:17
firmly rooted in the heads of many people in this country…
TCO:
10:56:41:14
TCI: 10:56:42:11
"I am just
a simple man,
but the State is great and mighty. "
TCO: 10:56:46:22
TCI: 10:56:49:01
Russia, Russia...
TCO: 10:56:51:01
TCI: 10:56:49:22
It is easy to rekindle the nostalgia of the older generation, but the young have no memories. Putin’s political advisors create a youth movement called « NASHI ».
One year after his election, 10 000 young people gather on the Red square to celebrate the anniversary.
In 2002 they are 20 000… in 2004, 50 000 …and in 2007 one hundred thousand.
TCO: 10:57:15:20
TCI: 10:57:19:16
Vassili Yakimenko
Leader of Nashi - youth movement TCO: 10:57:23:14
TCI: 10:57:17:17
15 years ago our nation
was strong and powerful
TCO: 10:57:22:01
TCI: 10:57:26:13
If we are not careful, our people
TCO: 10:57:29:04
TCI: 10:57:29:13
may disappear from the face of the earth.
TCO: 10:57:31:17
TCI: 10:57:35:21
Nashi, an army for Putin… funded by Gazprom! TCO: 10:57:38:21
TCI: 10:57:51:14 9/11/2001
Putin is the first head of state to to contact George W. Bush. This gesture brings him into the international limelight.
TCO: 10:58:00:15
Vladimir PUTIN TCI: 10:58:03:00
Russia knows what terrorism
means.
TCO: 10:58:05:14
TCI: 10:58:07:10
We understand how the American citizens are feeling today.
TCO: 10:58:14:18
TCI: 10:58:16:00
In the name of
Russia,
TCO: 10:58:18:04
TCI: 10:58:18:18
I would like to express our solidarity.
TCO: 10:58:22:08
TCI:
10:58:24:03
Zbigniew
Brzezinski
Geo strategist, former
statesman USA TCO:
10:58:29:11
TCI: 10:58:23:05
He sympathized and I presume,
sincerely so. But it was in the interest of Putin to ally himself with the United States and
insure that the enemies of Russia be perceived as terrorists.
TCO: 10:58:40:11
TCI: 10:58:42:05
Vytautas Landbergis
First president of Lithuania European MP
TCO: 10:58:48:01
TCI: 10:58:41:03
Of course
this friendship gave the time to Putinist
Russia to re- enforce its army,
threatening again the world as they announced, to keep our eyes off the
Russian
atrocities, equal to a genocide in Chechnya… Because
they are needed
for something else…
TCO: 10:59:18:12
TCI: 10:59:21:01
Moscow
24th May 2002
TCO: 10:59:24:15
TCI: 10:59:19:22
Since 9/11 the cold war has become past history, Russia and the USA are on their honeymoon. George W. Bush has been invited to Moscow to sign a treaty on the reduction of their nuclear arsenals that neither country has any intention of respecting…
The real reason for their meeting is quite different… The two presidents sign no less than 67 agreements on oil and gas.
Shortly afterwards, Vladimir Putin declares « Whoever controls the production, the distribution and the price of oil, controls power in today’s world. »
With emotion, George W Bush declares: « When I looked deep into the eyes of Vladimir Putin, I could see a fellow soul… »
TCO: 11:00:04:23
Vytautas Landsbergis TCI: 11:00:06:09
Looking into the
icy eyes of a KGB officer and being moved by the deepness of the soul …that is worrying!
The West will awake, but the West is losing the time. Losses in time can become losses in
independance!
TCO: 11:00:40:21
TCI: 11:00:56:19
J. Robinson West
US Consultant oil and gas TCO: 11:01:01:21
TCI: 11:00:54:22
Energy is at the centre of political operations in Russia just as much as its presence on the world stage.
TCO: 11:01:05:20
TCI: 11:01:09:21
Steven Dashevsky
Banker Aton-Invest Energy specialist TCO: 11:01:14:17
TCI: 11:01:07:02
If
he uses that as opposed to ideology as the foundation for an increased position in the world Russia is going to return to a significantly prominent position in global affairs.
TCO: 11:01:23:10
(Maps)
TCI: 11:01:26:09
American multinationals see Putin’s expansionism with a grim eye. They construct two pipelines by-passing Russia, from Bakou in Azerbaïdjan to Cehan.
The honeymoon between the USA and Russia is over. The first shots have been fired in the new energy war. TCO: 11:01:44:20
J. Robinson West TCI: 11:01:46:05
Pipe lines are different from just general
commercial agreements. Pipe lines are hardwire relationships, they,
represent an enormous investment of billions of dollars and they create a link
between countries that is really different from almost any other kind of
commercial arrangement
TCO: 11:02:03:22
TCI: 11:02:04:18
The Yukos oil tycoon, Mikhail Khodorkovsky, understood this link long before Putin’s arrival on the scene. At the fall of the Soviet Union he and other oligarchs had associated themselves with western companies exploiting Russian oil fields to make personal fortunes. Khodorkovsky plans to clinch further deals with the US.
TCO: 11:02:24:20
TCI: 11:02:29:07
He has also ignored Putin’s warning to keep out of politics. Putin’s reaction is as to be expected.
TCO: 11:02:37:15
TCI: 11:02:41:06
Like Gussinky and Berezovsky before him, Khodorkovsky is arrested for tax evasion. He is sentenced to 8 years in Siberia. His companies are taken over by Gazprom with support from the Western Banks invited to open branches in St Petersburg when a certain Vladimir Putin was deputy mayor…
Through the Yukos-Khodorkovsky affair, Putin makes it clear to the West that his new weapon is energy and nothing will stop him from using it to rebuild Russia’s greatness.
TCO: 11:03:10:15
TCI: 11:03:30:15
Irina Khakamada Chairwoman liberal party "The Choice"
TCO: 11:03:35:11
TCI: 11:03:22:07
The Khodorkovsky affair is a demonstration towards
the whole society
that state power is the
strongest institution in Russia. The president of Russia, the vertical of power
in Russia are an institution , something like the Byzantine system, Tsar, the tsar
decided it and tsar did it.
TCO: 11:03:40:20
TCI: 11:03:51:12
When Putin next summons the oligarchs, no-one evokes the subject which is uppermost in their minds: the fate of Khodorkovsky. If anyone dares contradict the president, they know they are out for good.
To elaborate his system of control Putin creates his own oligarchy. Former KGB officers or St Petersburg liberals, they are all state officials and members of his clan.
TCO: 11:04:18:18
TCI: 11:04:27:18
Garry Kasparov World chess champion
Leader United Civil Front TCO: 11:04:32:26
TCI: 11:04:21:06
Putin
runs a corporation. For him, Russia is a corporation, it’s a business. They’re nationalizing all the expenses
and privatizing all the profits.
Gazprom is one of the best
examples. The moment the gas enters the pipeline it’s a state monopoly. The
moment the gas is sold, it’s a private company. We have the
cleanest
oligarchal system in the history of the human race. Putin created this one. It’s time when there’s no difference, no frontier, no visible frontier
between business and the government. Money rules the country and the
government controls the money.
TCO: 11:04:55:17
TCI: 11:04:57:15
Gregory Yavlinski,
Leader Yabloko, democratic party TCO: 11:05:03:03
TCI: 11:04:56:07
The approach
is different, but the substance is the same.
In substance it means,
the law is not for us, we control justice, we control and do just whatever we
want. But he also brought ideology to this: This is how we will create great Russia.
TCO: 11:05:19:05
Lilia Shevtsova TCI: 11:05:20:02
Mr Setchin, Mr Patrouchev, Mr Ivanov, Mr Medvedev,
Mr Surkov … I’m not sure that the world knows them, but ofcourse the Russians do. They do know that Putin’s lieutenants, unfortunately
these people who rule Russia on behalf of the presidency, thEy don’t have one
important thing, they don’t have to have accountability for what they are
doing.
TCO: 11:05:47:16
Nina Krushcheva TCI: 11:05:48:00
That is vertical,
I mean you can’t be more vertical than that! And you know he did what he
promised, that’s what’s remarkable about him. When he promised, it sounded
as though it was going
to be beneficial to Russia,
but somehow, when we
turn around, all of this instead of benefiting us benefited his idea of the state. TCO:
11:06:08:06
TCI: 11:06:13:01
Vladimir Putin is candidate for a second presidential mandate in 2004. TCO: 11:06:17:16
Garry Kasparov TCI: 11:06:17:23
Opposition in Russia is not fighting
to win the elections. Opposition in Russia is fighting for having elections. Any
election held from 1993 to nowadays, has
been
marked by growing government interference. Today of course, it’s not an
election, it’s more of a soviet type vote when the results
are already fixed before
the election’s results are announced.
TCO: 11:06:40:21
TCI: 11:06:46:13
In March 2004, Putin wins the elections with an outright majority of 71%. He has 4 more years to consolidate his policies. He presides over what has become a single party system. His party renamed « Russia United » receives its orders from the Kremlin. Opposition parties have no power, political debate has ceased to exist.
TCO: 11:07:09:02
TCI: 11:07:17:01 UKRAINE
TCO: 11:07:20:03
TCI: 11:07:13:21
To regain control is also Putin’s objective for the former republics of the Soviet Union. They are more and more openly coveted by the United States who are eager to create a barrier to Russian expansionism.
Ukraine, symbolically and strategically the most important of these countries, is at the crossroads for the transit of Russian oil and gas to Europe.
TCI: 11:07:36:02
TCI: 11:07:48:10
Vladimir Poloholo Political analyst Ukraine
TCO: 11:07:52:09
TCI: 11:07:44:23
With the advent of
Putin,
TCO: 11:07:46:13
TCI: 11:07:46:19
a geopolitical project was
created
TCO: 11:07:49:16
TCI: 11:07:49:22
called the " Single
economic space ",
TCO: 11:07:52:15
TCI: 11:07:52:22
in which Russia had the main
role.
TCO: 11:07:56:15
TCI: 11:07:56:21
This project was entirely
anti-western and an attempt to weaken
TCO: 11:08:00:10
TCI: 11:08:00:16
the influence of Europe and the USA in
former soviet countries.
TCO: 11:08:06:15
TCI: 11:08:09:13
The Ukrainian presidential elections are in October 2004. The pro-Russian authoritarian régime is in difficulty, but Putin has no intention of letting Ukraine choose the path to democracy. The FSB and Putin’s advisors collaborate closely with Ukrainian intelligence services to ensure the victory of Putin’s protégé, Victor Yanukovitch. At the climax of the election campaign, Victor Yushenko, the pro- western candidate, is poisoned and badly disfigured. But this doesn’t deter him or the Ukrainain people.
On the 20th December after an agitated poll, the orange revolution leads him to victory.
TCO: 11:08:54:21
Vladimir Polohalo TCI: 11:08:59:11
It was an anti Russian revolution,
TCO: 11:09:01:05
TCI: 11:09:01:12
an anti imperialist revolution,
TCO: 11:09:03:17
TCI: 11:09:03:23
against the Kremlin Empire.
TCO: 11:09:06:21
TCI: 11:09:07:03
It was the most terrible failure of his whole political career.
TCO: 11:09:11:06
TCI: 11:09:13:19
For Putin it is more than a failure, it is a humiliation.
But, there are other ways to show Ukraine that she will not escape from Russia’s hold.
TCO: 11:09:22:03
TCI: 11:09:31:13
Vitaly Davij Journalist Energy specialist
TCO: 11:09:35:12
TCI: 11:09:22:16
After the orange revolution,
TCO: 11:09:24:15
TCI: 11:09:24:19
the energy
policy towards Ukraine became more and more brutal.
TCO: 11:09:28:16
TCI: 11:09:29:22
Gas and oil were used as levers
against the country.
TCO: 11:09:34:03
TCI: 11:09:36:18
On the 1st January 2006, the Kremlin cuts off the gas supplies to Ukraine. TCO: 11:09:41:17
TCI: 11:09:54:03
Vladimir Milov
Vice minister Energy
1st administration Vladimir Putin TCO: 11:09:59:04
TCI: 11:09:48:09
This action was, from the beginning, intended to show the Ukraine
and Europe how powerful Russia
is in terms of their influence in regards to gas supplies.
TCO: 11:10:00:10
TCI: 11:10:02:16
But the Kremlin’s black mail has only just begun. Parliamentary elections are coming up and Russia continues its intimidation by stopping the importation of Ukrainian goods.
Putin’s message is clear. The pro-Russian Yanoukovitch must become primeminister, if the Ukrainians vote for his party, everything will return to normal.
Today the deed is done, Yanoukovitch is primeminister and Ukraine is moving away from Europe and NATO.
In Ukraine he demonstrates his capacity to use any means to transform a failure into victory.
TCO: 11:10:40:06
Gleb Pavlovsky TCI: 11:10:42:24
I think
that today Putin feels
completely at ease.
TCO: 11:10:48:17
TCI: 11:10:49:02
He simply has a feeling of
superiority.
TCO: 11:10:53:12
TCI: 11:10:55:23
In my opinion this feeling
is totally justified...
TCO: 11:10:59:04
TCI: 11:11:01:04
Putin is right to be confident, he’s the king of the largest gas field in the world.
TCI: 11:11:06:06
Map GAS pipeline Baltic Sea
TCI: 11:11:10:11
Putin also signs an agreement with Chancellor Gerhard Schröder for a pipeline under the Baltic sea, linking Russia to Western Europe, making it more dependant on Russian gas… But he doesn’t stop there.
TCO: 11:11:22:20
Map GAS pipeline, Blue Stream
TCI: 11:11:25:22
He signs a treaty with another friend, Silvio Berlusconi… and the Turkish prime minister, for the construction of the Blue stream pipelines serving Central and Southern Europe.
Gazprom’s giant tentacles will not only engulf all European countries but also Japan, China, and South America: Putin’s objectives? A transnational government around Gazprom: Russia’s future challenge to American world dominance.
But, Gazprom is also oil, uranium, banks, the media, football teams… and its future business temple: an architectural feat, in St Petersburg.
Putin is at the summit of one the the most powerful empires in the world. TCO: 11:12:22:07
TCI: 11:12:25:10
Alexander Mynken
Editorialist Moscow Komsomolets TCO: 11:12:30:09
TCI: 11:12:24:10
The leaders of countries like
France, Germany,
the USA, England,
TCO: 11:12:29:10
TCI: 11:12:29:19
Japan, Canada,
Italy say to him,
TCO: 11:12:31:23
TCI: 11:12:32:15
"My dear friend, my dear friend
"!
TCO: 11:12:36:09
TCI: 11:12:39:08
You know what is happening in
Chechnya…
TCO: 11:12:41:22
TCI: 11:12:42:10
Your leaders know what Is going on there, TCO: 11:12:46:05
TCI: 11:12:46:20
but they say, "it
doesn't matter,
it doesn’t
matter…”
TCO: 11:12:50:06
TCI: 11:12:51:02
"Because we need the gas and oil,
So…”
TCO: 11:12:55:09
German language footage
TCI: 11:12:56:22
Gertie and Vladi...
TCO: 11:12:57:23
TCI: 11:12:58:17
Politics, for the better and for the worse...
TCO: 11:13:01:13
TCI: 11:13:08:09
Putin is so sure of his hold over European countries that when, during a summit, a French journalist criticises the war in Chechnya, he hits back below the belt…
TCO: 11:13:17:18
French journalist TCI: 11:13:18:11
By trying
to eradicate terrorism in Chechnya, do you not fear that you will eradicate the civilian population?
TCO: 11:13:31:01
Vladimir Putin TCI: 11:13:33:16
If you want to become
TCO: 11:13:35:06
TCI: 11:13:36:07
an
islamist fundamentalist and
be circumcised, TCO:
11:13:41:19
TCI: 11:13:42:01
come to Moscow,
we are multiconfessional,
TCO: 11:13:44:19
TCI: 11:13:45:10
we have very good specialists,
TCO: 11:13:47:14
TCI: 11:13:48:07
I can recommend one for the operation.
TCO: 11:13:52:20
TCI: 11:13:53:03
He'll make sure nothing grows back!
TCO:
11:13:55:11
TCI: 11:14:09:05
Beslan
3rd September 2004
TCO: 11:14:12:10
TCI: 11:14:08:17
A new tragedy reminds the Russians of the situation in Chechnya. Hostages taken by terrorists are held in a school in Beslan in the northern Caucasus. Russian special forces storm the school, 186 children can be counted among the 344 civilian victims.
The Kursk catastrophe in 2000, the hostage taking in a Moscow Theatre in 2002 and now Beslan. This is the third major crisis for Vladimir Putin in 4 years: Signs that his governance has serious flaws. Things have to change TCO: 11:14:46:01
TCI: 11:14:48:10
On the 31st January 2005, Putin declares that the war between Russia and Chechnya is over…Russia will no longer be responsible for the atrocities committed in Chechnya, Putin has transformed the conflict into a civil war by nominating, Ramzan Kadyrov, the son of the recently assassinated pro Russian president, as primeminister
Kadyrov’s ferocious militia replaces the regiments of the Russian army. TCO: 11:15:13:12
TCI: 11:15:15:22
Akhmed ZAKHAIEV
Former Chechen Minister of Culture TCO: 11:15:20:18
TCI: 11:15:13:13
Of course, today they
are
the only ones Putin can count on!
TCO: 11:15:19:20
TCI: 11:15:20:02
The war in Chechnya
has been raging for 10 years.
TCO: 11:15:23:24
TCI: 11:15:24:14
Today, Ramzan Kadyrov and his criminal murderers TCO: 11:15:30:21
TCI: 11:15:31:12
are implenting Putin's policies and his war in Chechnya.
TCO: 11:15:36:03
TCI: 11:15:39:00
Arseny Roginsky President Memorial NGO Human rights
TCO: 11:15:43:18
TCI: 11:15:37:10
One part of the Chechen population eliminates the other,
TCO: 11:15:42:05
TCI: 11:15:42:19
while the Russians turn a blind
eye...
TCO: 11:15:44:23
TCI: 11:15:45:07
Half of the population terrorises the other.
TCO: 11:15:49:13
TCI: 11:15:50:22
The majority of the population is afraid
TCO: 11:15:53:19
TCI: 11:15:54:06
and has a sense of total injustice.
TCO: 11:15:56:12
TCI: 11:15:58:22
The Kremlin offers a reward of 100.000 dollars for the assassination of the rebel leaders. In 2005 the first, Aslan Maskhadov, former elected president and protagonist for peace, is killed by the Russian special services. In 2006 it is the turn of Chamil Bassaiev the fundamentalist leader.
TCO: 11:16:18:15
TCI: 11:16:21:09
The wars in Chechnya have decimated 200 000 inhabitants: 20% of the population.
But more insidiously, Putin has destroyed the self respect and identity of a whole nation.
TCO: 11:16:32:24
TCI: 11:16:35:19
As for Gazprom, a new pipeline will soon be crossing Chechen territory, linking Bakou to Central Europe…
TCO: 11:16:42:09
TCI: 11:16:49:21
Nina Kruscheva Historian, New York
Grandaughter Nikita Krushchev TCO: 11:16:54:03
TCI: 11:16:43:12
After Beslan,
he was speaking and he said: “We’ve
been working very hard to salvage the remnants of the Soviet
Union anyway we possibly can” and I was shocked, I mean, I didn’t know that’s
what we were working on; in fact, I thought we
were working in an overcoming of those remnants. But
apparently not and that quote says it all in a way; that his mission is to
salvage the remnants of the Soviet Union, anyway we can... And that becomes
personal.
TCO: 11:17:11:18
TCI: 11:17:12:15
Any semblance of democracy has vanished. Putin installs an openly authoritarian regime. He personally nominates the regional governers and
magistrates, passes a decree reducing the freedom of journalists, another refusing visas for foreigners lacking in respect. The FSB creates groups of civilian informers, and to avoid a replica of the Ukrainain uprising, Putin reduces the possibility for foreign funding of NGOs.
When gagging the “enemy within” it is wise never to forget the “enemy without.”
TCO: 11:17:48:14
TCI: 11:18:03:07
Vilnius - Lithuania 4th May 2006
TCO: 11:18:06:21
TCI: 11:18:06:15
The Americans break their silence. TCO: 11:18:08:16
TCI: 11:18:12:20
Dick Cheney
Vice president USA TCO: 11:18:16:13
TCI: 11:18:09:19
No legitimate interest is served when oil and gas become tools of intimidation or blackmail either by supply manipulation or attempts to
monopolize its transportation. And no one can justify actions that undermine
the territorial integrity of a neighbour or interfere with democratic
movements. Yet in Russia today, in many areas of civil society, for religion
and the news media, advocacy groups and political parties, the government has
unfairly and improperly restricted the rights of the people.
TCO: 11:18:44:01
TCI: 11:18:46:12
Unlike the Europeans the Americans take Putin’s nationalist and authoritarian offensive very seriously. Their world dominance could be put to question. They announce their plan to install anti missile batteries in Eastern Europe. Putin retaliates.
TCO: 11:19:04:07
Vladimir Putin TCI: 11:19:04:18
The military budget of the
United States
is 25 times ours.
TCO: 11:19:11:00
TCI: 11:19:12:11
That signifies that their house is their fortress.
TCO: 11:19:18:07
TCI: 11:19:19:14
Clever,
TCO: 11:19:20:24
TCI: 11:19:21:09
very clever!
TCO: 11:19:22:08
TCI: 11:19:23:17
It means that we too must
build a strong and resistant house,
TCO: 11:19:29:13
TCI: 11:19:30:19
because we can see
what is going on in the world,
TCO: 11:19:32:22
TCI: 11:19:33:03
we know what is going on.
TCO: 11:9:35:07
TCI: 11:19:36:00
Our comrade, Mr Wolf, knows who to eat!
TCO: 11:19:38:17
TCI: 11:19:38:23
He devours other countries, heedless... TCO: 11:19:40:15
TCI: 11:9:41:01
He has no intention of listening to anyone.
TCO:
11:19:43:18
TCI: 11:19:48:24
Energy is considered to be Russia’s new strategic weapon but its nuclear arsenal has 8000 more nuclear war- heads than the USA.
Russia is the second biggest arms exporter in the world, supplying no less than 61 countries.
Between energy dependance and arms sales, Russia possesses the two most powerful geostrategic instruments in the world.
TCO: 11:20:12:08
TCI: 11:20:28:11
William Hartung
World Policy Institute, NY Arms specialist
TCO: 11:20:33:09
TCI: 11:20:20:05
The legacy of the
Cold War is that Russia and United States are still the two largest military
powers, self protective with their weapons,
especially nuclear weapons.
And since Russia has them in thousands that can reach the United States, in
terms of how US weapons are targeted, Russia is still by far the primary
target.
TCO: 11:20:37:24
TCI: 11:20:41:10
Putin
is willing to sell military nuclear technology to China, to Iran, to Venezuela… or to other
countries that the United States
is at least suspicious of if not actively hostile. But there
could come a point where it goes beyond that, you know, where Putin tries to
restore the kind of super power, proxy battles they had during the Cold War.
TCO: 11:21:05:10
Vladimir Putin TCI: 11:21:06:15
We are developing our nuclear
complex TCO:
11:21:09:21
TCI: 11:21:11:00
with a new system of ballistic weapons. TCO: 11:21:15:12
TCI: 11:21:17:11
Over the last two
years,
we have had incredible results.
TCO: 11:21:21:19
TCI: 11:38:19:24
With this nuclear complex,
TCO: 10:38:21:08
TCI: 11:21:24:16
we are way ahead,
for a long time to come,
TCO: 11:21:26:05
TCI: 11:21:28:15
of any other country
in the world.
TCO: 11:21:32:23
TCI: 11:21:35:10
Vytautas Landsbergis
First president of Lithuania European MP
TCO: 11:21:39:23
TCI: 11:21:34:00
We could see the world in 5 or 10 years when the Middle East is dominated
by Iran, with Russia in the background, where Americans are pushed out,
humiliated…, kicked.
TCO: 11:21:51:08
TCI: 11:22:00:19
Moscow
60th anniversary of end of 2nd World War TCO: 11:22:05:08
TCI: 11:22:47:01
Nina Krushcheva Historian, New York
Grandaughter Nikita Krushchev TCO: 11:22:51:24
TCI: 11:22:37:20
Russians
today love Putin. I mean, look at the polls. I mean it says that 65% support
Putin, it’s a huge approval rate! He may look as if he is attending to people’s businesses because that’s what we see on TV and, you know, very much
like Stalin in fact. We saw Stalin attending to the public and being an expert
in everything from, studying of languages to international politics, to
athletics, whatever! Putin is kind of the same thing. And while in Stalin’s
case maybe, he needed some sort of arm twisting for people to believe that he
was the greatest; in Putin’s case, somehow, it all happens voluntarily.
TCO: 11:23:15:20
TCI: 11:23:22:20
Vladimir Ryzhkov
Co-chairman Republican party TCO: 11:23:27:12
TCI: 11:23:16:10
This popularity
is illusion. If you switch on Russian news, every night, you will see Putin only with good news; never bad news. It’s a joke that if Putin is on the TV screen: it’s good news. If
somebody else is, it’s maybe bad news. But never Putin, only good news: he
increases pensions, he increases salaries, he’s fighting oligarchs, he’s
speaking with Bush, Schröder and Merkel. Brejnev was a super star, Stalin was
super star: in every authoritarian regime, there is only one super star.
TCO: 11:23:53:16
TCI: 11:23:55:04
Mikhail Berg Philosopher
Author of "A letter to our president" TCO: 11:23:58:16
TCI: 11:23:54:21
I know certain young people in business,
TCO: 11:23:58:18
TCI: 11:23:59:17
who are not interested in the past or in politics, TCO: 11:24:04:11
TCI: 11:24:05:15
everything suits them in general...
TCO: 11:24:07:19
TCI: 11:24:08:04
These people are very numerous.
TCO: 11:24:09:12
TCI: 11:24:12:05
These people belong to the system,
TCO: 11:24:13:18
TCI: 11:24:14:06
…to the Putin system.
TCO: 11:24:16:07
TCI: 11:24:17:08
They close their eyes to
the lack of freedom, TCO:
11:24:21:14
TCI: 11:24:22:11
they don't see the necessity...
TCO: 11:24:23:20
TCI: 11:24:26:16
In Moscow today, consumerism is the new religion.
The heart of the Russian capital throbs to the inflow of gas and petrodollars and the more you pay the better!
Moscow has overtaken the West at incredible speed: Casinos, giant advertisments, luxury stores, top - priced cars, traffic jams all day long… No other capital in the world counts so many millionaires.
A new middle class has emerged doping retail sales. The richest buy yachts, private jets, works of art, skiing resorts… In London, where the most expensive properties are the new datchas of the Moscovites, some business tycoons even invest in famous football clubs… while near Moscow itself, the trendiest create country clubs - Russian style!
TCO: 11:25:15:19
TCI: 11:25:29:20
Garry Kasparov World chess champion
Leader United Civil Front TCO: 11:25:34:17
TCI: 11:25:17:12
Putin’s
regime is very good in creating illusions that reflect the general belief that
Russia’s economy is growing and blossoming and, of course, in the centre of
Moscow, you get these feelings. If you start travelling 50 miles outside the
centre of Moscow, it’s like taking a ride in a time machine. In St Petersburg, you don’t have to go that far:
about a hundred meters from Nevski prospect: one way or another, and
you’re immediately entering Dostoïevski’s St Petersburg of the 19th
century.
TCO: 11:25:46:11
TCI: 11:26:15:21
The enemies of the soviet régime like the intellectuals and the former dissidents that support the Sakharov Foundation are the targets of Putin’s régime as in the days of Yuri Andropov. These men and women contested the injustice, the repression and the very essence of the soviet system and often paid for it in the gulag.
TCO: 11:26:35:10
TCI: 11:26:50:07
Yuri Samodurov
Director Sakharov Foundation TCO: 11:26:55:03
TCI: 11:26:37:08
Nobody, in my generation,
TCO: 11:26:40:15
TCI: 11:26:40:22
thought they would see
TCO: 11:26:44:22
TCI: 11:26:45:22
the end of the soviet system and the fall of communism…
TCO:
11:26:47:17
TCI: 11:26:49:02
When, it finally happened,
TCO: 11:26:51:24
TCI: 11:26:52:12
we thought it would never return.
TCO: 11:26:56:09
TCI: 11:27:06:08
But, it has…
TCO: 11:27:08:15
TCI: 11:27:12:03
The presidential elections of 2008 are approaching. The pervading atmosphere created by the régime incites acts of violence towards its opponents. Disillusioned, one of Putin’s former advisors, Marat Guelman, has created an alternative movement where art is a means of expression. His gallery is ransacked.
TCO: 11:27:30:12
TCI: 11:27:40:23
Marat Guelman Art Collector
Political technologist TCO: 11:27:45:11
TCI: 11:27:34:11
I
was afraid they'd
decide to finish me off... so I started to shout.
TCO: 11:27:40:24
TCI: 11:27:43:02
One of them told me to shut up and I shouted even louder.
TCO: 11:27:46:24
TCI: 11:27:47:18
The other one threw the computer
at me and they left…
TCO: 11:27:52:12
Young demonstrators TCI: 11:27:56:24
No to repression!
TCO: 11:27:58:17
TCI: 11:28:01:21
December 2005
TCO: 11:28:04:19
TCI: 11:28:00:09
Not all young people have been won over by Putin like « Nashi » or the
« Young Guards », a political movement. Twenty teenage activists occupy a citizens’ complaints’ bureau in the Presidential Administration, demanding Putin’s resignation.
Seven are sentenced to 5 years in jail. TCO: 11:28:22:22
TCI: 11:28:33:06
Elysée Palace
23rd September, 2006
TCO: 11:28:36:20
TCI: 11:28:33:16
On the 23rd September 2006 Putin receives the Légion d’honneur from President Jacques Chirac.
Strangely, only Russian television is permitted to film the event… TCO: 11:28:46:23
TCI: 11:28:55:11
Serguey Kovalev
Former dissident and MP TCO: 11:28:59:24
TCI: 11:28:53:18
Why do world leaders
queue up
TCO: 11:28:57:13
TCI: 11:28:57:19
to shake Putin’s hand ?
TCO: 11:28:59:20
TCI: 11:29:00:09
Does he deserve
people to shake his hand ?
TCO: 11:29:03:00
TCI: 11:29:03:23
Nobody asks themselves that question!
TCO: 11:29:07:18
TCI: 11:29:09:22
Anna Politkovskaya is the 22nd journalist assassinated since Putin’s arrival in power. She was about to publish an investigation on the torture carried
out in Chechnya by primeminister Ramzan Kadyrov’s armed gangs. She is killed at gunpoint, in the entrance to her appartment block, on October 7th 2006, Vladimir Putin’s birthday…: a sinister birthday present commissioned perhaps by Kadyrov himself.
Five months later in March 2007, Putin « appoints » him as President of the Republic of Chechnya.
TCO: 11:29:48:04
TCI: 11:29:57:03
Alexander Litvinenko, former officer of the FSB was also a defender of the Chechen cause. He emigrated to London after denouncing the implication of the FSB in the Moscow bomb explosions imputed to the Chechens in 1999.
TCO: 11:30:12:06
TCI: 11:30:05:22
Alexander Litvinenko Former officer FSB London, October 2006
TCO: 11:30:11:12
TCI: 11:30:16:08
After having published her
book « Russia according to Putin
» Anna had received threats several
times, directly from the Kremlin.
During our last meeting she asked me, do you think
they can kill me?
TCO: 11:30:38:01
TCI: 11:30:40:23
Alexander Litvinenko will never reveal the conclusions to his investigation on Anna Politkovskaya’s murder.
Poisoned by a highly radioactive substance, he dies one month later. TCO: 11:30:53:08
TCI: 11:31:05:15
Anna Politkovskaya (Foreign
agent…)
TCO: 11:31:13:08
TCI: 11:30:55:06
A list of 100 people to be eliminated was put into circulation on the internet. Several people interviewed in this film are on the list. They have nevertheless accepted to voice their opinions.
TCO: 11:31:06:10
Yuri Felshtinski TCI: 11:31:13:03
I
think that the choice of the moment of the assassination of Litvinenko,
TCO:
11:31:18:17
TCI: 11:31:19:08
and that of Anna
Politkovskaya
TCO: 11:31:22:06
TCI: 11:31:22:20
were linked
with the presidential campaign of 2008.
TCO: 11:31:27:01
TCI: 11:31:30:14
Who do these crimes benefit? Several theories exist but the absence of rule of law in Russia makes it improbable that those behind the murders ever be brought to justice.
If the constitution is not modified Putin cannot be a candidate for a third term of office in 2008. But he can be again in 2012, or maybe even before… who knows?
TCO: 11:31:56:09
Lilia Shevtsova TCI: 11:31:59:15
Putin has been smart
enough to organise
a new configuration of power
creating several kinds of groups apparently understanding that if he has
only one group, to rely on, he’ll be tied to it, he’ll lose his independence and he won’t be able to survive. He can only survive by being an arbitrator,
the upper judge presiding over the bickering of the dogs behind the cupboard.
TCO: 11:32:26:21
Garry Kasparov TCI: 11:32:27:22
Losing power means at best losing the property they acquired, but more likely losing freedom. So they’re fighting
for their survival.
Staying in the Kremlin is the only guarantee, the only immunity
against imminent prosecution, because what they committed staying there, the
way they acquired their multi billion dollar fortune, will be inevitably
investigated.
TCO: 11:32:56:16
Nina Krushcheva TCI: 11:32:59:10
I think as
brilliant as he is, he may not even need to change the constitution to get what
he wants.The KGB mind, as simple as it is, is also very devious and devious to
the point that normal minds cannot comprehend or predict. So, this would be my amendment, even if he doesn’t change
it, we have certain things in
store…
TCO: 11:33:20:16
Gregori Yavlinsky TCI: 11:33:28:15
So
the day you finalize your movie, things can change dramatically. The main
forecast for Russia is unpredictability because Russia is in transition, is a very unstable authoritarian system and
everything can happen.
TCO: 11:33:48:12
TCI: 11:33:54:09
Anything is indeed possible in Russia, but unpredictability never goes beyond these stairs. Within the secrecy of the Kremlin walls, the leader and his cabal control the state, the economy… and the destiny of the people.
TCO: 11:34:09:22
TCI: 11:34:11:20
Vladimir Putin has succeeded in his « mission ». He has established the vertical of power, stabilized the economy and made Russia an important player on the world stage again…
TCO: 11:34:22:04
TCI: 11:34:26:19
The former KGB is more powerful than ever before in history. TCO: 11:34:30:14
TCI: 11:34:32:15
But what choice do the Russian people really have?
Whatever Putin’s régime be called a « Dictocracy » or a « militocracy », his chosen successor will continue to perpetrate his system, privatizing the state with former members of the KGB, ignoring the rule of law and curbing freedom of thought.
TCO: 11:34:51:22
TCI: 11:34:54:12
As for Russia’s economic and diplomatic confrontation with the United States, its impact on the re-division of the world will concern not only the Russian people but also the future of us all.
TCO: 11:35:06:2
TCI: 11:35:19:21
Written and directed by Jean-Michel Carré TCO: 11:35:23:16
TCI: 11:35:24:12
And
Jill Emery
TCO: 11:35:27:10
TCI: 11:35:28:05
Editor
Michèle Hollander
TCO: 11:35:30:22
TCI: 11:35:31:19
Archivist Masha Oleneva
TCO: 11:35:34:11
TCI: 11:35:35:6
Paintings
Andrey Boudayev
TCO: 11:35:37:23
TCI: 11:35:38:18
Music composed
by Benoit Jarland Marc Tomasi TCO:
11:35:41:09
TCI: 11:35:42:05
Narrators Geoffrey Bateman Jill Emery
TCO: 11:35:44:22
TCO: 11:35:46:23
CREDITS
TCO: 10:37:13:24